For months, US economic data has shown resilience, with layoffs remaining low and business activity staying steady despite fears over policy uncertainty. But the tide may be shifting. Multiple data points this week have shown signs of slowing as a wide swath of tariffs has been in effect.
On Thursday, weekly filings for unemployment benefits hit their highest level since October 2024, adding to a slew of data showing a cooling economy leading into the Friday morning release of the May jobs report.
Earlier in the week, the Institute for Supply Management’s Services PMI registered a reading of 49.9 in May, below the 51.6 seen in April. Readings above 50 for this index indicate an expansion in activity, while readings below 50 indicate contraction. May’s data marked just the fourth time the services sector has fallen into contraction in the past five years.
Jefferies US economist Tom Simons wrote in a note to clients that the ISM services data likely reflects “more signs of a pause in activity rather than a steep contraction.”
“A broad pause is not a good thing, and the uncertainty that precipitated this pause has not shown any signs of lifting,” Simons wrote.
And it’s not just one sector pressing pause as tariffs take hold. On Monday, the ISM’s manufacturing PMI also showed contraction in May as imports hit their lowest level since 2009, with a wide swath of President Trump’s tariffs taking hold.
Economists have reasoned that it’s not just the tariffs themselves causing businesses to slow activity. It’s the uncertainty of where policy — and eventually the broader economy — is headed in 2025. That includes the labor market: In May, the private sector added 37,000 jobs, the lowest monthly total in more than two years, per ADP data released Wednesday.
“When it comes to hiring, there’s a hesitancy because of a wide level of uncertainty,” ADP chief economist Nela Richardson told Yahoo Finance during a call with reporters.
“We’re in a situation now where businesses are facing a level of paralysis,” RBC Capital Markets economist Carrie Freestone told Yahoo Finance on Wednesday. “Nobody is wanting to ramp up hiring when they don’t know what’s going to happen down the line.”
The slowdown in hiring has likely led to an increasing number of workers staying unemployed for longer. Data from the Department of Labor released Thursday morning showed 1.904 million workers filed for continuing unemployment benefits in the week ending May 24. The data is hovering near its highest level since November 2021.
ADP’s Richardson said the challenge facing corporates is akin to driving through fog. Usually, the driver keeps moving forward but drives slower and more carefully. Whether the fog gets worse or clears in time for the labor market rebound remains key to the economic story as the summer approaches and investors receive more data showing how tariffs are impacting the outlook.
“I do think that once the uncertainty clears a bit, you’ll see more activity in the labor market,” Richardson said.
But other economists have pointed out that the data shows a clear sign that the labor market is on thin ice.
“We’re getting close to some soft employment numbers,” Renaissance Macro head of economics Neil Dutta wrote in a note following Thursday’s unemployment benefits release. “The broader story here is that with the hiring rate still quite low, it would not take much in the way of layoffs to generate some weak payroll prints.”
Josh Schafer is a reporter for Yahoo Finance. Follow him on X @_joshschafer.
Click here for the latest economic news and indicators to help inform your investing decisions
Read the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance